COVERGIRL Super Sizer Mascara Review 2026: Volume, Performance & Comparison
Big, bold lashes can change your whole look. COVERGIRL Super Sizer Mascara promises just that. It claims up to 400% corner to corner volume for a dramatic lash effect.
But does this drugstore mascara actually deliver? We put it to the test to find out.
This mascara comes in waterproof and non-waterproof formulas. Both promise a Very Black shade that makes your eyes pop. The brush and formula work together to coat every lash.
In a Nutshell
- Volume boost: This formula delivers 400% corner to corner volume, giving lashes a dramatic lift.
- Wear time: It stays put for 12+ hours without losing its hold.
- Application: The brush glides on smooth, so you get even coverage in one swipe.
- Minor downside: Some users notice slight clumping near the end of the day.
- Water caution: The non waterproof version can smudge if your eyes water.
- Color and size: It comes in a single Very Black shade and a compact 0.4 fl oz tube.
- Customer rating: Shoppers give it a solid 4.3 out of 5 stars on Walmart.
- Competition: It holds its own against names like Maybelline Sky High and L’Oréal Telescopic.
Formula and Volumizing Technology
The formula behind Super Sizer Mascara focuses on one main goal: extreme volume. COVERGIRL engineered this mascara to coat each lash from root to tip with a thick, buildable formula. The result is lashes that look fuller and more dramatic with every application.
The volumizing technology works through a combination of waxes and pigments. These ingredients cling to your lashes and create a lifting effect instantly. You don’t need multiple coats to see results, though you can add more if you want extra drama.
The brush design plays a key role in how well this mascara performs. The wand is slightly curved and features densely packed bristles. This shape helps the formula reach even the smallest lashes in the corners of your eyes. The bristles separate lashes while depositing color, which prevents clumping during application.
One standout feature is how the formula stays put. Once applied, it locks onto your lashes for 12+ hours without flaking or smearing. This means your lashes look bold from morning through evening without touch ups needed.
The waterproof version uses a water resistant base that holds strong even in humid conditions. The non waterproof formula offers easier removal, though it’s less resistant to moisture. Choose waterproof if you want maximum staying power through sweat or tears.
Build ability is another strength of this mascara. You can apply one coat for natural volume or layer multiple coats for a bolder look. The formula doesn’t get goopy or clumpy with each layer, at least during the first few hours of wear.
Some users report slight clumping appears later in the day, particularly if you apply thick coats. This happens because the formula continues to set and can become slightly tacky. A quick lash comb can separate any stuck lashes if needed.
The overall formula is designed to deliver volume without weighing lashes down. This keeps your lashes lifted and defined all day long. For anyone seeking dramatic volume at a drugstore price point, this mascara delivers on its promise.
Last update on 2026-10-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
Application and Texture
The brush design makes a huge difference with this mascara. The wand features densely packed bristles that grab each lash from root to tip. You get even coverage in just one or two swipes, which means faster application time.
When you first apply Super Sizer, the formula feels smooth and creamy. It glides across your lashes without tugging or pulling. The slightly curved wand follows the natural shape of your eye, so you can coat upper and lower lashes with ease.
The texture is where this mascara shines. It’s not too thick or too thin. The consistency allows you to build volume gradually if you want extra drama, or keep it light for a more natural look. Many users appreciate that you control the intensity based on how many coats you apply.
One thing to note: the formula does thicken slightly as you layer coats. This is great for volume seekers, but it means you need to be careful about overdoing it. Applying too many coats too quickly can lead to minor clumping, especially by mid afternoon.
The removal process is surprisingly easy. Unlike some volumizing mascaras, this one doesn’t require harsh rubbing. A gentle makeup remover or micellar water takes it off without leaving residue. Your lashes stay healthy and intact.
If you have sensitive eyes, the non waterproof version tends to be gentler overall. However, keep in mind that it can smudge if your eyes tear up or if you’re in humid conditions. The waterproof formula solves this problem completely, though it does require a bit more effort to remove.
Application time is quick, making this mascara great for busy mornings. The brush control is excellent, so you won’t accidentally get product on your eyelid. Overall, the application and texture work together to deliver the dramatic volume this mascara promises.
Wear Time and Longevity
Super Sizer Mascara keeps your lashes looking bold for a full day of wear. The formula holds strong for 12+ hours, which means your lashes stay lifted from morning through evening without drooping or losing volume.
The waterproof version performs best if you deal with humidity, sweating, or tears throughout the day. It creates a water resistant base that locks in the color and volume. Your lashes maintain their dramatic look even in challenging conditions.
The non waterproof option works well for dry environments. It removes easily at the end of the day, which is a major plus if you have sensitive eyes or prefer a gentler formula. Just be aware that this version can smudge if your eyes water unexpectedly.
Longevity depends on how you apply it. One thin coat lasts the full 12 hours without any flaking or smearing. If you layer multiple coats for extra drama, some users notice slight clumping appears later in the day. This happens because the formula thickens as you build it up, so apply with a light hand if you want flawless wear until bedtime.
The brush design helps extend wear time too. The curved wand grips each lash evenly, so the formula stays distributed along the entire lash line. Uneven application can lead to faster fading in certain spots.
Temperature and moisture levels affect how long this mascara lasts on your lashes. In cooler, drier conditions, you get the full 12 hours easily. In hot or humid weather, the non waterproof version may need a touch up midday.
Removal is straightforward, which means the formula doesn’t harden or flake off during the day. It washes away with warm water and a gentle cleanser, so you won’t spend extra time scrubbing at night.
Overall, Super Sizer Mascara delivers consistent, long lasting wear that keeps up with your daily routine. The 12 hour hold makes it reliable for work, errands, and evening plans without touch ups needed.
Top 3 Alternatives
Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara
Last update on 2026-10-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
This mascara gives you bold, fanned-out lashes without the heavy feeling. The brush has curved bristles that grab every lash from root to tip. You get volume and length in just a few swipes. The formula stays put all day without flaking or smudging.
Many users love how easy it is to apply. You don’t need a steady hand or special technique. The wand glides smoothly and separates lashes naturally. It works well for both thick and thin lashes.
L’Oreal Voluminous Mascara
Last update on 2026-10-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
L’Oreal’s formula focuses on dramatic volume and shine. The brush is wider and fuller than most, coating each lash evenly. You get instant thickness that lasts from morning to night. The mascara has a creamy texture that feels lightweight.
This option works great if you want bold results without drama. It layers well, so you can add more coats for extra volume. The formula removes easily with warm water or makeup remover. Your lashes feel soft and conditioned after use.
Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara
Last update on 2026-10-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
The name says it all—this mascara prevents clumping completely. The unique brush design separates each lash individually. You get defined, separated lashes with natural-looking volume. The formula is waterproof and long-wearing.
Perfect for everyday wear, this mascara builds gradually. Start with one coat for subtle definition or add more for drama. It removes without tugging or damaging lashes. Users appreciate how it works on short and long lashes alike.
Waterproof vs. Non-Waterproof Options
The choice between waterproof and non-waterproof Super Sizer Mascara comes down to your lifestyle and eye environment. Both versions deliver the same 400% volumizing power, but they handle moisture differently.
The waterproof formula uses a water-resistant base that locks in place even when humidity, sweat, or tears come into play. This version excels if you exercise regularly, live in humid climates, or cry easily. The pigments stay put throughout the day without budging. Many users report zero smudging or flaking, even after 12+ hours of wear.
The non-waterproof option works best in dry environments where you don’t encounter much moisture. This version tends to be gentler on sensitive eyes and removes much more easily. You won’t need makeup remover or vigorous rubbing. Simply wash with water and a gentle cleanser. The trade-off is that this version smudges if your eyes water unexpectedly or if you’re caught in humid conditions.
Application feels identical with both types. The curved brush glides smoothly across your lashes, and the creamy formula builds volume without clumping on the first coat. Some users notice slight clumping appears later in the day, particularly if you apply thick layers. This happens with both versions, though the waterproof formula holds stronger overall.
Longevity differs between the two. The waterproof version stays flawless for the full 12 hours in most conditions. The non-waterproof version performs best if you keep your eyes dry and avoid humid environments. Temperature and moisture levels affect how long each formula lasts on your lashes.
Removal is where they truly differ. The non-waterproof version washes off instantly with water. The waterproof version requires makeup remover or a cleansing oil. If you have sensitive eyes or prefer quick removal, the non-waterproof choice saves time and effort.
Choose waterproof if you need reliable performance in unpredictable conditions. Choose non-waterproof if you prioritize easy removal and have naturally dry eyes. Both deliver the same bold volume and lash-lifting effect that makes Super Sizer stand out.
Lash Lift and Definition
COVERGIRL Super Sizer Mascara excels at lifting and defining your lashes with its innovative formula. The 400% volumizing power creates a dramatic lift from root to tip, making your lashes appear fuller and more dramatic instantly.
The lash-lifting effect works because the formula clings to each lash without weighing it down. You get immediate separation and definition with just one or two coats. The brush design plays a key role here. Its shape allows you to coat each lash individually, which enhances the lifting action significantly.
Definition stays sharp throughout the day. The formula doesn’t clump or blur your lash lines, even after 12 hours of wear. This means your lashes maintain their distinct, sculpted appearance from morning until evening. The smooth texture ensures even coverage, so you avoid those patchy spots that ruin definition.
Layering coats intensifies the lifting effect without sacrificing clarity. You can add more product to build the look you want. The formula thickens slightly as you layer, but it remains controlled and defined. This gives you flexibility to go from natural to bold depending on your mood or occasion.
The lash-lifting benefit extends to your entire eye area. Lifted lashes make your eyes appear larger and more awake. This is especially noticeable if you apply the mascara to your upper lashes only. The lifting action opens up your eye shape beautifully.
One important note: the formula performs better as a volumizer than a lengthener. If you’re seeking dramatic length, this mascara might not be your best match. However, for definition and lift, it delivers excellent results consistently.
The waterproof version maintains its lifting properties even when humidity or moisture appears. Your lashes stay lifted and defined regardless of weather or tears. The non-waterproof option performs equally well for lift and definition in dry conditions.
Overall, Super Sizer Mascara creates a lifted, defined look that lasts all day. Your lashes appear fuller, darker, and more sculpted with minimal effort.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Delivers 400% volume with a smooth application that skips clumping and flaking
- Lifts and defines lashes without weighing them down, keeping definition sharp for 12+ hours
- Removes easily without hardening or leaving residue on your lashes
- Waterproof version handles humidity, sweat, and tears without smudging
- Works well with layering for extra intensity without losing clarity
Cons
- Focuses on volume more than length, so it won’t dramatically extend your lashes
- Non-waterproof formula smudges if your eyes water or you’re in humid conditions
- Some users report light clumping toward the end of the day with heavy application
Who Should Buy It
Super Sizer Mascara works best for people who want dramatic volume without the weight. If your lashes fall flat by midday, this formula lifts and holds them in place for the entire day.
You should buy it if you prefer volumizing mascaras over lengthening ones. The formula builds thickness across your lash line instead of stretching them outward. Layering multiple coats intensifies the effect while keeping your lashes defined and separated.
This mascara suits anyone with normal to dry eyes. The non-waterproof version works perfectly in controlled environments where moisture isn’t a concern. You get smooth application and easy removal without any hassle.
Choose the waterproof formula if you deal with humidity, sweat, or emotional tears regularly. Athletes, gym enthusiasts, and people in hot climates benefit most from this option. It stays put through unpredictable conditions while maintaining the same lifting benefits as the regular version.
Super Sizer Mascara is ideal for people who want quick morning routines. Application feels smooth and effortless. You won’t spend extra time fixing clumps or uneven coverage. The formula goes on cleanly and dries fast.
This product works well for anyone who values easy removal at night. You won’t need special makeup remover or aggressive scrubbing. The mascara releases cleanly without leaving residue on your lashes or eyelids.
Skip this mascara if you have naturally short lashes and need significant lengthening. The formula focuses on volume rather than extension. You’ll get fuller lashes, but they won’t look dramatically longer.
Avoid the non-waterproof version if your eyes water frequently or you live in humid climates. Moisture causes smudging and breaks the wear time. The waterproof option solves this problem completely.
People who layer mascara heavily should monitor application toward the end of the day. Some users notice light clumping with thick coats after 12 hours of wear. Start with thin layers and build gradually for best results.
Overall, Super Sizer Mascara suits anyone seeking volume, easy application, and reliable performance throughout the day.
Final Verdict
Super Sizer Mascara earns its spot as a solid volumizing pick. Shoppers give it a strong 4.3 out of 5 stars on Walmart, showing real trust from everyday users.
When you place it next to competitors like Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High or L’Oréal Paris Telescopic Original, the difference becomes clear. Those formulas lean toward length. Super Sizer leans toward bold, full volume instead.
Essence Lash Princess also competes in this space, but it often adds extra weight to lashes. Super Sizer keeps things lighter while still delivering a dramatic look.
The Very Black shade gives strong pigment in just one swipe. You get an intense, bold finish without needing multiple coats for color depth.
The wand shape also deserves a mention here. Its design helps the brush glide through lashes smoothly, which supports that even volume from root to tip.
This mascara fits well into everyday makeup routines. It works for quick morning looks and also holds up for evening wear without extra touch ups.
If you want a mascara that focuses purely on size and drama, this one checks that box. It skips the fuss of extra steps or layering tricks.
For anyone comparing formulas on the shelf, think about your main goal first. Do you want big, bold volume or do you want longer lashes? That answer should guide your final pick.
Super Sizer Mascara stands out as a dependable choice for volume lovers. It keeps your lashes looking full without feeling heavy or stiff throughout the day.
Overall, this mascara earns a strong recommendation for anyone chasing a voluminous lash look. It performs well against its competitors and keeps a loyal fan base happy.
If bold, dramatic lashes are your priority, this pick deserves a spot in your makeup bag. It delivers on its main promise and keeps things simple along the way.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Super Sizer Mascara work on short lashes?
Super Sizer Mascara focuses on volume and thickness rather than length. If your lashes are naturally short, this formula won’t add much extension. You’ll get a bold, fuller look, but the lashes stay roughly the same length. Consider a lengthening mascara if stretch is your main goal.
Can I wear this mascara if my eyes water easily?
The non-waterproof version will smudge if your eyes tear up or you’re in humid conditions. Switch to the waterproof formula if you cry easily, live in a humid climate, or spend time outdoors. The waterproof option resists moisture and stays put all day without budging.
How does Super Sizer compare to Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High?
Both mascaras deliver volume, but they work differently. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High adds more length and lift. Super Sizer Mascara prioritizes pure volume and thickness instead.
Super Sizer also has a smoother application and removes more easily. Choose Super Sizer if drama and thickness matter most to you.
Is this mascara good for sensitive eyes?
The formula doesn’t contain harsh irritants and removes without tugging or leaving residue behind. Most people with sensitive eyes tolerate it well.
If you have very reactive eyes, test it on one eye first. The waterproof version may feel slightly heavier, so the regular formula might feel more comfortable for daily wear.
Can I layer Super Sizer Mascara for extra drama?
Yes. Layer it without losing clarity or creating clumps. Apply one coat, let it dry, then add another. The formula stays separated and builds beautifully.
Heavy layering may cause slight clumping toward the end of the day, so stick to two coats for the cleanest finish.
Hi i’m Mia Jenkins a fashion trend expert with a passion for self-expression, skincare, haircare and makeup. With a keen eye for style and a deep understanding of the latest trends and beauty products.
